Managing Difficult Conversations: The Art of Not Making Things Worse

Connect with us: SB Nation | Managing Madrid Community | Dray's Bay Forums | Canis Hoopus

The worst workplace conversation I ever witnessed happened in a Brisbane office lift between floors 12 and 14. Two sentences. Thirty-seven seconds. One resignation letter handed in that afternoon.

Here's what most people get wrong about difficult conversations: they think the goal is to win. Wrong. Dead wrong. The goal is to not lose your best people, your reputation, or your sanity in the process. After nearly two decades of watching managers botch these interactions spectacularly, I've developed some strong opinions about what actually works.

The Pre-Game Ritual That Changes Everything

Before you even think about opening your mouth, you need to get your head right. I'm not talking about some new-age meditation nonsense—I'm talking about practical preparation that separates the professionals from the amateurs.

Write down three things: what you want to achieve, what you're afraid might happen, and what success looks like for both parties. Sounds simple? Most managers skip this entirely and wonder why conversations derail faster than a Melbourne tram in peak hour.

The biggest mistake I see is people diving straight into problem-solving mode without understanding the emotional landscape. You might think Sarah from accounting is being defensive about the budget discrepancies, but maybe she's dealing with a sick parent and working 60-hour weeks. Context matters.

Timing Is Everything (And Most People Get It Wrong)

Friday afternoon difficult conversations should be illegal. Seriously.

You know what else should be banned? Ambush conversations. "Hey, can I see you in my office right now?" is the workplace equivalent of starting a sentence with "We need to talk." Everyone's stress levels just spiked unnecessarily.

The sweet spot is Tuesday to Thursday, between 10am and 3pm, when people aren't rushing to start their day or escape to their weekend. Give people advance notice—not three weeks, not three minutes. "I'd like to discuss the Melbourne project with you tomorrow at 2pm. Is that timing good for you?"

See how that works? You've respected their time, given them mental preparation space, and avoided the anxiety-inducing vagueness that makes people imagine worst-case scenarios.

But here's where I probably differ from other consultants: sometimes you need to have the conversation immediately. If someone's about to make a catastrophic error or there's a safety issue, protocols go out the window. Use your judgement. You have it for a reason.

The Opening Move That Sets the Tone

Forget everything you learned about small talk. Skip the weather, skip asking about their weekend. Get to the point, but do it with respect.

"Thanks for making time to discuss this. I want to talk about the client feedback we received yesterday. Before we dive in, I want you to know this conversation is about finding solutions, not assigning blame."

That's it. You've established purpose, timeline, and intention in two sentences. Compare that to the usual rambling approach: "So, how was your weekend? Good, good. Nice weather we're having. Say, I wanted to chat about something that came up yesterday, well actually it was more like last week, but anyway..."

Stop wasting everyone's time.

The Secret Weapon: Strategic Silence

Here's something they don't teach in communication workshops: silence is not your enemy. Most Australians are uncomfortable with conversational gaps longer than 2.3 seconds (I made that statistic up, but it feels accurate). We fill silence with noise, clarifications, and backtracking that dilutes our message.

When you've said something important, shut up. Let it land. Count to five in your head. You'll be amazed how often the other person provides exactly the information or acknowledgment you need.

I learned this technique from watching a Canberra mediator handle workplace disputes. She would ask a question, then sit back like she had all day. People would eventually fill that space with honesty they wouldn't have shared otherwise.

Dealing with Emotional Reactions (Without Becoming a Counsellor)

When people get upset, managers panic. They start apologising for things that aren't their fault, making promises they can't keep, or rushing to fix problems that might not actually exist.

Your job isn't to eliminate all negative emotions—it's to create space for them without letting them derail the conversation. Here's what that looks like:

"I can see this is frustrating for you. Take a moment if you need it."

"It sounds like there's more to this situation than what we initially discussed."

"I'm hearing that the deadline pressure is a real concern for you."

Notice what you're not doing? You're not dismissing their feelings, but you're also not taking responsibility for managing their emotional state. That's their job.

The Follow-Up That Actually Matters

Most managers think the conversation ends when people leave the room. That's like thinking a surgery is complete when you've finished cutting—the real work happens during recovery.

Send a follow-up email within 24 hours summarising what was discussed and any agreed actions. Not because you don't trust their memory, but because clarity prevents future conflicts. Include deadlines, next check-ins, and any resources you promised to provide.

But here's the part that separates good managers from great ones: check in informally within a week. Not about the specific issue, just generally. "How are things going?" can reveal whether your difficult conversation actually resolved anything or just pushed problems underground.

When Things Go Sideways (And They Will)

Sometimes conversations explode despite your best efforts. Someone storms out. Voices get raised. Accusations fly.

First: don't take it personally. Second: don't try to solve everything in one session. Third: know when to call time-out.

"I think we both need some time to process this. Let's reconvene tomorrow morning at 9am to continue this discussion."

You're not giving up—you're being strategic. Heated conversations rarely produce useful outcomes, and pushing through when emotions are running high often makes situations worse.

I once watched a Sydney manager try to power through a conversation where an employee was clearly overwhelmed. Forty minutes later, that employee was in tears, the manager was frustrated, and nothing was resolved. A simple "Let's pause here and pick this up tomorrow" would have saved everyone unnecessary stress.

The Uncomfortable Truth About Difficult Conversations

Here's what most business books won't tell you: some difficult conversations don't have happy endings. Sometimes people need to leave. Sometimes projects fail. Sometimes relationships can't be repaired.

Your job isn't to fix everything—it's to handle conversations professionally, with dignity, and in a way that preserves relationships where possible. But if someone consistently underperforms after multiple conversations, or if behaviour issues continue despite clear feedback, trying to avoid difficult decisions just makes everything harder for everyone else.

The goal isn't to be liked by everyone. The goal is to be respected as someone who addresses issues directly, fairly, and without unnecessary drama.

Getting Better at Something You'll Always Hate

Let's be honest: most people will never enjoy difficult conversations. They're called difficult for a reason. But you can get better at them, and that competence makes them less stressful for everyone involved.

Practice matters. Role-play with trusted colleagues. Attend workshops that focus on practical scenarios rather than theoretical frameworks. Record yourself (audio only) during low-stakes conversations to hear your verbal patterns and filler words.

Most importantly, get feedback. Ask people you trust: "How did that conversation feel from your perspective?" You might discover you interrupt more than you realise, or that your helpful suggestions come across as micro-management.

The best managers I know treat difficult conversations like any other skill—something you can improve with deliberate practice and honest self-reflection.

The Bottom Line

Managing difficult conversations well isn't about being perfect—it's about being prepared, respectful, and focused on outcomes rather than egos. Most workplace drama could be avoided with better communication, but that requires managers willing to have honest conversations before small issues become major problems.

Some conversations will still be uncomfortable. Some people will still react poorly. Some situations won't have ideal resolutions. But if you approach these interactions with clear intentions, practical strategies, and realistic expectations, you'll handle them far better than most managers ever do.

And your team will notice the difference.

The lift conversation I mentioned at the beginning? It happened because a manager avoided a difficult conversation for three months, letting resentment build until a casual comment triggered an explosion. Don't be that manager.

Address issues early, directly, and professionally. Your future self will thank you for it.

---

Want to improve your approach to workplace communication training? Sometimes the best investment is learning from people who've made all the mistakes already.